Recomp guide: when the scale won’t move
Updated 19 November 2026
You train, you eat to a plan, and three weeks later the scale reads the same. On a recomp that can mean fat is coming off while your muscle holds or grows. It can also mean the plan isn’t doing what you meant it to. This guide helps you tell which, and what to change.
It’s for people who lift and want to lose fat while keeping or building muscle. It’s general information, not medical advice, and no plan promises a result.
Why the scale stalls
The scale weighs everything: fat, muscle, water and the food you’ve just eaten. Lose a little fat and gain a little muscle and the total barely moves, even though your body changed.
Day to day, the number also swings for reasons that aren’t fat loss. In a study of 80 adults who weighed in daily, weight was higher early in the week and fell through it. The authors say such swings should be considered normal (Orsama et al., Obesity Facts, 2014). Your body also stores carbohydrate as glycogen with three to four parts water to each part, so a few days of more or less carbohydrate can move the scale with no change in fat (Kreitzman et al., American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1992).
What to watch instead
Your weight trend. Weigh in most days and read the average, not today’s number. Tholve’s Weight page draws your trend as the average of the last 7 days and shows how fast it moves each week. It appears once 3 of those days have a weigh-in.
Your lifts. More reps at the same weight, or more weight for the same reps. A meta-analysis of trials of lifters training in an energy deficit found strength gains comparable to those of lifters eating enough, though lean-mass gains were smaller (Murphy and Koehler, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 2022). So your lifts can climb while the scale holds still. Tholve’s Train tab keeps a record for every lift.
Your protein. Hit your target on most days. Today in Tholve shows the protein you have left.
A flat trend, rising lifts and protein on target is what a working recomp can look like. A flat trend with flat lifts is the case to look into, below.
Set your calories
A recomp eats at maintenance or a little under. In Tholve’s Calorie Plan, Recomp offers those two: At Maintenance, or A Little Under, about 10% under what you burn. If you burn 2,500 calories a day, that’s 2,250. You pick one, and the plan never picks a deficit for you.
Keep the deficit small. Murphy and Koehler’s meta-analysis found lean-mass gains were smaller in a deficit, and its meta-regression suggested a deficit of about 500 calories a day prevented them. In a trial of 24 elite athletes who kept lifting four days a week, the group aiming to lose 0.7% of body weight a week gained 2.1% lean mass, and the group aiming for 1.4% a week didn’t (Garthe et al., International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism, 2011).
Start at maintenance if training comes first. Start 10% under if you want fat loss to have a push, and expect the scale to move slowly either way. The recomp calculator works out both for you.
Training is the other half. A 2020 review of recomposition in resistance-trained people names progressive resistance training and sound nutrition as the two key factors (Barakat et al., Strength & Conditioning Journal, 2020). Keep adding reps or weight over the weeks.
Set your protein
The International Society of Sports Nutrition says 1.4 to 2.0 grams of protein per kilogram of body weight per day is sufficient for most exercising people to build or maintain muscle (ISSN position stand, Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2017). In a meta-analysis of 49 trials of lifters, gains in fat-free mass levelled off at about 1.6 g per kg a day, with a wide margin: the 95% confidence interval ran from 1.03 to 2.20 (Morton et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2018). So 1.6 is a sensible place to start, and the range around it is wide.
Tholve’s Calorie Plan can suggest 1.6 g for each kg you weigh if you lift. At 75 kg, that’s 120 g. You can switch the suggestion off and type your own target in Enter Targets.
The same position stand adds that resistance-trained people eating below maintenance may need more, 2.3 to 3.1 g per kg a day, to keep the most lean mass. Pick a target you can hit on most days and hold it for the two weeks.
When to change the plan
Give each plan two weeks. Weight follows a weekly rhythm, so compare whole weeks instead of single days. Two weeks after you start a plan, Tholve’s Plan Check-In compares your average weight in the first week with the second, next to the food you logged, and you choose Keep Plan or Recalculate. The weight comparison needs a weight on at least 3 days in each week. Tholve never changes your targets on its own.
- Trend flat, lifts rising, protein on target. Keep the plan.
- Trend flat, lifts flat. Check that your log matches what you ate, then change one thing. If you’re at maintenance and want fat to drop, move to A Little Under. If you’re already there, look at your training and protein before you cut calories further.
- Trend rising week after week. Check your log against the plan. If you didn’t plan to gain, move one step down, from maintenance to A Little Under.
- Trend falling faster than 1% of body weight a week, or lifts going down. Eat more. A review for natural bodybuilders recommends losing about 0.5 to 1% of body weight a week to maximise muscle retention (Helms et al., Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, 2014). At 80 kg, 1% is 0.8 kg.
Change one thing at a time, then give it two more weeks.
Each part has its own guide: protein, calories, a weekly tracking routine and progressive overload.
Track your recomp in Tholve
Tholve keeps what this guide watches in one app for iPhone and Apple Watch: a training log with a record for every lift, your weight trend, and the protein you have left today. Pick Recomp in the Calorie Plan, and the Plan Check-In puts two weeks of food and weight side by side. You decide what changes.