Progressive overload: are your lifts going up?
Updated 5 November 2026
Your lifts are going up when you do more reps at the same weight, or the same reps at a heavier weight, on the same exercise done the same way. Compare each set with the last time you did that exercise. When you reach the top of your rep range on every work set, add a small amount of weight and build the reps back up. That’s progressive overload, and a training log is how you see it.
This page is for people who log their sets, whether in a notebook or an app.
Two ways to progress
More reps at the same weight. Last week 80 kg for 8, 8 and 7. This week 80 kg for 9, 8 and 8.
More weight for the same reps. Last week 80 kg for 10. This week 82.5 kg for 10.
Both count. In a trial of 43 people with at least a year of lower-body training, one group added weight while keeping reps the same and the other added reps while keeping the weight the same, for eight weeks. Both groups gained muscle and strength, with Smith machine squat 1-rep max up about 20 kg on average, and the differences between them were small (Plotkin et al., PeerJ, 2022).
When to add weight
A common way to combine the two is double progression. Pick a rep range, such as 8 to 12. Keep the weight until you reach 12 on every work set, then add weight and work back up from about 8.
The American College of Sports Medicine recommends adding 2 to 10% to the load once you can do the current weight for one or two reps more than your target (ACSM position stand, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2009). On a 100 kg squat that’s 2 to 10 kg. On a 10 kg dumbbell it’s 0.2 to 1 kg, so on small lifts you may stay longer at each weight and add reps instead.
Comparing sets with different reps
Was 100 kg for 5 better than 90 kg for 8? An estimated 1-rep max puts both on one scale. Epley’s formula, which Tholve uses, is weight × (1 + reps ÷ 30):
- 100 kg × 5 reps: 100 × (1 + 5 ÷ 30) ≈ 117 kg
- 90 kg × 8 reps: 90 × (1 + 8 ÷ 30) = 114 kg
So the set of 5 at 100 kg was slightly stronger. Treat the result as an estimate for comparing your own sets. It isn’t a tested max.
Compare like with like
Progress only shows when the sets are comparable:
- Same exercise, same setup. A barbell bench press and a dumbbell bench press are different lifts, and so are two machines from different makers.
- Work sets only. Leave warm-ups out of the comparison.
- Same rest and order, as far as you can.
Log how hard each set was
Reps alone don’t say whether 12 reps were easy or all you had. Reps in reserve (RIR) is how many more reps you could have done: 0 means you couldn’t do another. It maps onto a 1 to 10 effort scale, where 10 is 0 reps in reserve and 9 is 1 (Zourdos et al., Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2016).
Logged with each set, it shows progress the weight and reps can miss: the same 80 kg for 10 with 3 reps left this week, where last week it took everything.
On a recomp
Your lifts can still go up while you eat at maintenance or a little under. A meta-analysis of lifters training under maintenance found strength gains comparable to those of lifters eating enough, though lean-mass gains were smaller (Murphy and Koehler, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 2022). That makes your lifts worth watching while the scale holds still. How to track recomp progress puts them in a weekly routine, and the recomp guide covers what to change when everything stalls.
If your lifts are flat for a few weeks, check your calories and protein before you change your training. The recomp calculator works out both.
Track your lifts in Tholve
Tholve’s Train tab logs every set on iPhone or Apple Watch, with reps in reserve if you want it. It keeps records for each exercise: heaviest weight, estimated 1-rep max (from work sets of 2 to 10 reps), best set (weight × reps) and most volume in a workout, each compared only with sets of the same exercise done the same way. With Tholve Plus, you can turn on weight suggestions for an exercise: once you reach the top of your rep range with 2 or more reps in reserve on every work set, two workouts running at the same weight, it offers one step up of at most 5%. You choose whether to use it.